Food Farming and the Environment

FOOD, FARMING AND THE ENVIRONMENT are complex systems and the SFADG entry over the last two months (and over time) has highlighted that there are still many big holes in our understanding of, and measurement tools for, how to properly account for the impacts of different foodstuffs on the environment and on health, which is not acknowledged in an article in The Conversation entitled “Meat tax: no UK politician is calling for one – but maybe they should” – see here. However, would this put agro-ecological farmers out of business whilst increasing large-scale, intensive farming, to cut costs of production? Might there be better ways that support high animal welfare whilst, at the same time, tackling multiple environmental problems. For example, recently some farmers have been cutting the size of their cattle herds due to less grass, due to less Nitrogen fertiliser application, due to shortages and high prices. In Jan 2023, the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) said here that nitrogen pollution is one of the most important pollution issues facing humanity. Here are four reasons why humanity needs to limit nitrogen pollution:

1. Nitrogen pollution is disrupting life on land and underwater

2. Nitrogen is a key contributor to climate change

3. Nitrogen pollution is a threat to human health

4. Nitrogen waste weighs on the economy

UNEP states that excess nitrogen in the environment in a reactive form comes from the use of synthetic fertilizers, the discharge of wastewater or the combustion of fossil fuels. The Soil Association highlights the effects of synthetic nitrogen on wildflowers, woodlands, soils and aquatic life. See here.

Also, taxing Ultra-Processed Foods (UPFs), rather than meat per se, might achieve better targeted outcomes for health and the environment. See ‘Ultra-processed foods should be central to global food systems dialogue and action on biodiversity’ (Leite FHA et al, BMJ 2022) here. As well as species loss, the paper indicates that UPF production is associated with “large quantities of land, water, energy, herbicides and fertilisers; and causes eutrophication and environmental degradation from greenhouse gas emissions and accumulation of packaging waste.” So, campaigning for a meat tax, is not in my view the best way forward. Decreasing agri-chemical use and ultra-processed food consumption are just two ways that might have more positive impacts on the environment.